Understanding How Malpractice Law Holds Medical Professionals Accountable

December 8, 2025

Healthcare is one of the most critical aspects of our lives, yet even in the most advanced medical systems, mistakes can happen. Patients trust medical professionals with their well-being, often in vulnerable moments, and when something goes wrong, there needs to be a way to hold providers accountable. That’s where malpractice law comes into play. It serves as a vital safeguard, ensuring that doctors, nurses, and other healthcare professionals adhere to established standards of care while providing a path for patients to seek justice when harm occurs.


Understanding how the law works isn’t just important for medical professionals—it’s essential for patients and families alike. From preventing errors to promoting transparency, this legal framework touches nearly every aspect of healthcare. According to Forbes, one in three medical providers are sued for malpractice during their careers, highlighting just how common these legal matters can be. In this article, we’ll explore the history, purpose, and impact of malpractice law, examining how it protects patients, guides professionals, and shapes the future of medical accountability.


Ensuring Accountability in Healthcare


The importance of malpractice law in healthcare cannot be overstated. This legal framework exists to ensure that doctors, nurses, and other medical professionals provide care responsibly and ethically. Every patient deserves safe, competent treatment, and when errors occur, there must be a mechanism to hold the responsible parties accountable. This law provides that mechanism. It not only serves as a way for patients to seek justice but also functions as a deterrent, encouraging medical professionals to adhere to established standards and best practices.


 While lawsuits may seem alarming, they play a critical role in keeping the healthcare system accountable. They provide a structured way to investigate claims, determine if errors occurred, and ensure that appropriate actions are taken. Ultimately, malpractice law serves the dual purpose of protecting patients while reinforcing the responsibilities of medical professionals.


Medical errors can happen in any healthcare setting. From small clinics to large hospitals, no facility is entirely immune. What makes the law essential is its ability to maintain a balance: safeguarding patient rights while allowing medical providers to continue practicing responsibly. Through clear legal standards, healthcare professionals are encouraged to stay up to date with evolving medical knowledge and practices, which benefits everyone in the long run. Patients also gain confidence knowing that legal protections exist, encouraging open communication with their providers and fostering a culture of trust in healthcare. Awareness of these protections can also empower patients to ask questions, seek second opinions, and take an active role in their care.


Tracing the History of Medical Liability


Medical liability developed from the basic idea that patients deserve safe, responsible care. As healthcare grew more complex, so did the expectations placed on medical professionals. Communities began creating guidelines to help ensure that providers acted with care, communicated clearly, and respected the well-being of those they treated.


Over time, these early expectations turned into more organized systems meant to address concerns when something went wrong. Rather than focusing on blame alone, medical liability gradually shifted toward promoting safer practices, encouraging transparency, and giving patients a way to voice their experiences.


Defining Standards and Responsibilities


At the core of malpractice law is the standard of care, which establishes what competent medical professionals are expected to do in specific situations. When a provider deviates from these standards and harm occurs, the law ensures accountability and offers a pathway for patients to seek remedies.


A malpractice claim typically involves four elements: duty of care, breach, causation, and damages. Duty of care refers to a professional’s obligation to provide treatment according to accepted practices. A breach occurs when this duty is not met. Causation links the breach to the harm experienced, and damages reflect the impact on the patient. This framework ensures claims are evaluated fairly and consistently.


Standards of care are also dynamic. As medicine advances, so do expectations for outcomes. Emerging technologies, new treatments, and updated clinical practices all influence how the law is applied, ensuring patients are protected in an evolving healthcare landscape. These standards are vital not only for litigation but also for guiding healthcare providers in everyday decisions, encouraging a proactive approach to safety and ethical care. They also help medical teams establish internal protocols and continuous quality improvements to prevent mistakes before they happen.


Identifying Common Types of Claims


Medical errors can arise in many ways, and malpractice law covers a variety of scenarios. Misdiagnosis or delayed diagnosis is one of the most common areas. Failing to recognize or correctly interpret symptoms can worsen conditions, and legal accountability encourages careful assessment, thorough testing, and proper documentation.


Surgical and anesthesia errors, while less common, carry serious consequences. Mistakes such as wrong-site procedures, retained instruments, or improper dosing highlight the need for meticulous protocols. Medication errors, including incorrect prescriptions or administration, also fall under legal scrutiny. Obstetric and childbirth-related incidents, such as delayed cesarean sections or improper monitoring, can have lasting impacts on both mother and child.


By addressing these areas, the law not only provides recourse for affected patients but also encourages improvements in medical practices and patient safety. Additionally, awareness of these common claims helps patients become more informed and engaged in their healthcare, fostering a collaborative approach to treatment and prevention of errors. 


Understanding Professional Consequences


Facing a malpractice claim can be challenging for healthcare providers. Legal outcomes may involve financial settlements or court judgments. Professional licenses may also be impacted by investigations or disciplinary actions, even when claims do not result in legal penalties.


Claims can also take a psychological toll. Anxiety, stress, and burnout are common among healthcare professionals involved in litigation. Financial impacts extend beyond settlements, including legal fees, insurance premiums, and potential lost income. Through risk management, documentation, and adherence to standards, providers can reduce the likelihood of claims and maintain professional stability. Building a culture of safety within healthcare practices not only protects patients but also supports the mental well-being and confidence of medical staff. 


Exploring the Role of Insurance


Malpractice insurance complements malpractice law by protecting medical professionals from the financial risks associated with legal claims. Policies typically cover legal defense costs, settlements, and court awards, allowing providers to focus on patient care with confidence.


The presence of insurance also indirectly promotes patient safety. Knowing that legal and insurance scrutiny will occur encourages healthcare providers to follow established protocols, communicate effectively, and document care thoroughly. Together, insurance and the law form a system that balances patient protection with professional security, supporting ethical and accountable healthcare practices. Furthermore, insurance providers often offer risk management resources, helping practitioners prevent mistakes and improve patient outcomes over time. This proactive approach highlights how legal frameworks and insurance work hand in hand to strengthen healthcare systems overall.


Looking Ahead in Medical Accountability


As healthcare continues to evolve, malpractice law must adapt to new challenges. Telemedicine, artificial intelligence, and digital health tools all introduce complexities in defining responsibilities and ensuring patient safety. Legal frameworks are adjusting to address these technologies while maintaining accountability.


Future reforms are likely to emphasize prevention, education, and alternative dispute resolution methods like mediation or arbitration. These approaches can reduce stress and costs while fostering cooperation between patients and providers. By focusing on accountability, safety, and fair legal processes, the law will continue to protect patients and guide healthcare professionals. If you or a loved one have been affected by medical negligence, contact The Edmond Firm for support navigating
malpractice law and safeguarding your rights.


medical malpractice attorney
August 20, 2025
Discover the benefits of using a medical malpractice attorney, from protecting your rights to securing fair compensation after negligence or medical errors.
malpractice attorneys
March 18, 2025
Have you been involved in the legal system? This guide explores how malpractice attorneys use technology to enhance evidence management and case efficiency.
malpractice attorney
November 18, 2024
In this article, we discuss the three factors you should consider when choosing a malpractice attorney. Read on to learn more about this helpful topic.
malpractice law
August 19, 2024
Read our blog to discover how to find the perfect lawyer for your needs. Contact us for malpractice law services and more today!
malpractice lawyers
March 7, 2024
Here are four questions to ask malpractice lawyers during a consultation. If you or someone you love has been a victim of medical malpractice, contact us today.
February 7, 2024
Jessica Ross and Treveon Isaiah Taylor, Sr., the parents of a child who tragically died during a difficult birth last summer, spoke Wednesday following news that the death was officially ruled as a homicide by the medical examiner's office. The Clayton County Medical Examiner's Office said the cause of death was from a "fracture-dislocation with complete transection, upper cervical spine and spinal cord." It also said that ruling the manner of death as a homicide means the death was caused by the actions of another person. At this time, there is no word on whether charges will be filed against anyone in light of the news. Clayton County Police are still investigating the case. Lawyers for the family touched on the multiple lawsuits launched behind the death, including against the hospital, which the council alleges attempted to cover up the child's manner of death. Taylor said, "We want justice for our son; they lied to us." Meanwhile, Ross was next to his side, fighting to hold back tears. She eventually left the room. "It's been tough on the whole family," one of the lawyers told reporters. "They have been strong and resilient." The family's legal team also specified that they are still working to depose all those who were in the room at the time of the birth. 11Alive's Molly Oak spoke with the family after the press conference. The parents opened up more about the pain they're dealing with. "I just want justice for my baby boy. I’m hurt. I’m hurt bad. [The doctor] hurt me. She took my baby," said Ross. "She didn’t show no emotions. I just want justice for my baby." Both Ross and Taylor said the hospital staff did not allow them to hold their child after delivery. They said not being able to carry their child, one that bears Taylor's name, still causes them pain. "It hurts, it hurts. Because I wanted to hold him, and they kept telling me no," Ross said as she started crying. Shaking his head in disbelief, Taylor said he didn't get to touch the infant. He said the delivery process and outcome was "shocking" and still gives him "chills." "Because they lied to us," Taylor said, saying he's experienced a mix of emotions. "They played in our face. They tried to cover it up. They didn’t tell us the details of what happened." Both the couple and their lawyers said they want answers and need people to speak up. "Just come forward, please. The nurses that was in the room. Please just come forward please. I just want justice for my baby," Ross said tearfully. She thinks about her baby every day and said she doesn't think she will ever heal from this. " I know he's watching over us," Taylor added.
malpractice lawyer
November 9, 2023
In the event that you need to pursue a malpractice case, it's important to hire an expert malpractice lawyer. Read here to learn about their services.
September 13, 2023
After suffering the horrific loss of their first child during delivery July 10, 2023, parents Jessica Ross and Treveon Isaiah Taylor, Sr. were shocked to learn that the doctor they hired to conduct an autopsy following their baby's death by decapitation secretly recorded graphic video of his medical examination of their baby and posted the video to his Instagram account, all without the family's knowledge or permission. Ms. Ross and Mr. Taylor filed a lawsuit earlier this week against Dr. Jackson Gates and Gates Rapid Diagnostic Laboratory of Atlanta alleging invasion of privacy, intentional infliction of emotional distress and fraud. According to the complaint, Ms. Ross paid Dr. Gates $2,500 to conduct a postmortem examination. The contract did not give Dr. Gates permission to film the examination or disseminate video of said examination. The complaint contends that in addition to suffering the heartbreaking loss of their first child, Ms. Ross and Mr. Taylor were outraged when they learned that Dr. Gates had posted several videos of the grisly and graphic video to his Instagram account. The family's attorneys sent a cease-and-desist letter to Dr. Gates advising him to immediately remove the videos from his account. "After suffering one of the most heartbreaking losses any family could ever endure, Jessica Ross and Treveon Isaiah Taylor, Jr. had salt poured into their unfathomable emotional wounds when they discovered that video of their baby's very graphic medical examination had been made public by the very doctor they entrusted to conduct the autopsy. This is one of the most egregious and outrageous cases of 'clout chasing' we have ever encountered. Dr. Jackson Gates attempted to exploit our clients horrific loss to boost his own social media profile, without permission of the family. We intend to ensure that Dr. Gates is held accountable for this unbelievable invasion of our clients' privacy. We have also reported this incident to the medical examiner's board for their investigation." The couple are represented by attorneys Dr. Roderick Edmond and Keith Lindsay of Edmond & Lindsay, LLP along with attorney Cory Lynch of The Law Office of Cory J. Lynch, LLC.
August 11, 2023
20-year-old Jessica Ross and her boyfriend Treveon Isaiah Taylor, Sr. were eagerly awaiting the birth of their first child July 9 but were devastated to learn that not only did their baby not survive the delivery, he was tragically decapitated in the process. Ms. Ross and Mr. Taylor will today announce that they have filed a lawsuit against the doctor, the hospital, several nurses and the medical group who delivered their decapitated baby. During the attempted vaginal delivery, the baby’s shoulders got stuck in the vaginal canal (shoulder dystocia). The complaint alleges that the obstetrician, Tracey St. Julian, M.D., negligently applied excessive force on the baby’s head and neck during the attempted vaginal delivery resulting in the baby’s decapitation. It also alleges that Dr. St. Julian and the hospital nurses failed to do a Cesarean section on Mr. Ross in a timely manner, failed to call in a timely manner to get help from other healthcare providers as well as other allegations. According to the complaint, the baby's legs and torso were delivered through the incision in Ms. Ross’ uterus without the head. The baby’s head was then delivered vaginally. In the complaint, Ms. Ross and Mr. Taylor also allege that the doctor and the hospital engaged in intentional fraud and an attempt to coverup the fact that their baby was decapitated. More specifically, the complaint contends that Dr. Tracey St. Julian purposefully did not tell Ms. Ross and Mr. Taylor that their baby had been decapitated when she initially spoke with the couple a few hours after the delivery. Also, healthcare workers at the hospital knowingly lied to the young couple by falsely telling them that a free autopsy was not an option for them under the circumstances. The complaint alleges that this false information was given to avoid a forensic autopsy and to obstruct the gathering of evidence. Furthermore, the complaint alleges that healthcare providers at the hospital pressured the young couple to cremate their baby in an attempt to destroy evidence. When the Ms. Ross and Mr. Taylor demanded to see and hold their baby, hospital staff told them that they were not allowed to touch or hold their child. Hospital staff allowed the young couple to only view their dead child, not hold or touch him. During this viewing, their baby was wrapped tightly in a blanket with his head propped on top of his body in a manner such that those viewing him could not identify that he had been decapitated. Ms. Ross and Mr. Taylor were not told about the decapitation until July 13, 2023, 3 days after the delivery and a full day after Ms. Ross had been discharged from the hospital. The couple are represented by attorneys Dr. Roderick Edmond and Keith Lindsay of Edmond & Lindsay, LLP along with attorney Cory Lynch of The Law Office of Cory J. Lynch, LLC.  Media contact: Ryan Julison Edmond & Lindsay, LLP and The Law Office of Cory Lynch, LLC